There are many differences so let’s compare in detail the two leading 3D CAD software solutions.
Many users make the assumption, that because they look similar, that there is no significant difference between Inventor and SOLIDWORKS, and this couldn’t be further from the truth. Despite their similarities, SOLIDWORKS as a solution often offers more functionality, ease of use and much greater support through VAR’s. Developed and published by Autodesk ( more commonly known for their AutoCAD product line), Inventor is a 3D CAD modeling solution with a large global presence and is arguably one of SOLIDWORKS biggest rivals. This blog post will delve into some of the differences between the SOLIDWORKS and Autodesk Inventor, in order to give users a much more informed perspective to choose between the two. HardSoft offer SOLIDPLANS that can help you choose the right SOLIDWORKS license.
SOLIDWORKS compared to Inventor
Despite looking similar, Inventor often falls short of the depth of the SOLIDWORKS, often requiring complex workarounds. Some of the areas its that Autodesk inventor shows a lack of depth compared to SOLIDWORKS are:
SOLIDWORKS has more advance and parametric sketch functions, with much better ease of use as seen below:
|Dimensioning tool||Less functional, and requires additional clicks for alignment||More streamlined into sketching, with advanced text functionality such as symbols, and comments|
|Editing||Change in geometry can cause instability at times||Remains stable no matter the geometry change|
|Sketch constraints||Less user friendly||Extremely user friendly and easy to learn.|
Compared to Autodesk Inventor, SOLIDWORKS has much more powerful solid feature options, allowing for much more complex geometries to be created faster and easier.
|Extrude And revolve features||Extrude/revolve start and end conditions must be a surface.||Start and end conditions can be surfaces, vertex’s and offsets from either|
|Hole Wizard||• End conditions: Blind and through all |
• Slots: no
• Hole on non-planar surface: Requires creation of additional plane
| • End condition: blind, through all, up to next, up to vertex, up to surface and surface offset|
• Slots: Yes
• Hole on non-planar surface: Can be placed on any face
|Sweep||• Profile complexity: Limited|
• Bidirectional sweep: not possible
|• Profile complexity: capable of sweeping complex profiles|
• Bidirectional sweep: Yes
|Patterns||• Linear/rectangular paths: yes but cannot skip instances |
• Circular: Available but cannot skip instances.
| • Linear/rectangular paths: Yes, with functionality to skip instances.|
• Circular: Yes, with functionality to skip instances.
• Other patterns: Sketch driven, Curve driven, table driven, fill pattern.
When modeling with assemblies SOLIDWORKS offers far more Mating, inspection functionality, with far more added support for large assemblies, as seen below:
|Mates|| • Standard mates: Coincident, parallel, perpendicular, Concentric, distance, Angle.|
• Width mate: No
• Mechanical mates: Few.
|• Standard mates: Coincident, parallel, perpendicular, Concentric, distance, Angle.|
• Width mate: Yes
• Mechanical mates: More advances mates
|Assembly inspection||Only Interference detection available||Interference detection, Clearance verification, Hole alignment available for use.|
|Large Assembly support||Only Resolved and expressed file opening options available.||Resolved, lightweight, large assembly mode, Large design review, available to open.|
While both offer the ability to create drawings, SOLIDWORKS offers more options, as well as ease in creating drawings.
|Dimension favourites||Note available||Available, dimensions can also be customized to include annotations from user.|
|Creating views||Must be inserted from file||Can be dynamically placed and dragged from the view pallet, which will also display a preview of all the available modes.|
SOLIDWORKS 3D cad also offers a far more complete package with a range of different functions covering the whole design process (such as simulation), whereas Inventor is solely a 3D CAD modeling software.
SOLIDWORKS vs Inventor pricing
SOLIDWORKS is also a better alternative for long term businesses as it is a perpetual license and with SOLIDPLANS financial solution comes with the pricing benefits of a subscription model.
All Autodesk products are only available on a subscription licensing, which can be renewed monthly, yearly or every 3 years, however as a subscription it means that you will never truly own it, unlike SOLIDWORKS in which the license is perpetual (meaning you own it). This means that as a long term business solution it is a cheaper and more convenient option.
At SOLIDPLANS by HardSoft the real advantage over conventional SOLIDWORKS VARs and AutoDesk is we offer a SOLIDWORKS Perpetual license (you own it) but on a 2 or 3-year monthly payment – Subscription Pricing with all the benefits of Perpetual Licensing.
SOLIDWORKS products and Autodesk products
SOLIDWORKS additional applications are often more in-depth in their functionality with interfaces similar across all applications, in order to facilitate ease of use.
Both Autodesk and SOLIDWORKS offer a large range of different software packages along with their 3d CAD software, such as SOLIDWORKS simulation or Autodesk’s fusion 360. However many Autodesk applications are “light” or limited versions of existing products, not containing all their functionality. What’s more is that Autodesk’s separate applications often feel like whole new products and interfaces, that not only make collaboration between these products difficult but due to the often obscure workflow needed to move data from one application to another, can often be very time-consuming. This is not the case with SOLIDWORKS as all application use the same interface allowing changes to be made dynamically and realized instantly
SOLIDWORKS support and Autodesk support
While both offer support to users, through its VARs, SOLIDWORKS has much greater depth in the support that it can offer to its users, through the entirety of the software to user support. Inventor has not offered much in the way of product enhancements in 30 years and users do not typically rely on the support for how to use the software, so much as for troubleshooting and OS issues. More than likely their only Autodesk contact is for yearly renewals, which not always, but often leads many Autodesk user’s to become frustrated. Meanwhile, SOLIDWORKS offers some of the best SOLIDWORKS reseller support available, with the largest support network available. SOLIDWORKS offers a global accreditation system for all forms of SOLIDWORKS application, in which a SOLIDWORKS reseller will certify themselves in in order to be able to fully support users not only in software issues and use, but training, which can be found in classes, E-classes, online resources such as mysolidworks, reading material and within the software itself.
Despite their similarities in appearance SOLIDWORKS offers a much more comprehensive design solution due to superior functionality, better pricing options, more in-depth additional products and greater VAR support.
If you’d like to find out more about SolidPlans by HardSoft or to talk to our resident SOLIDWORKS technical expert, give us a call on 020 7111 1643 or email firstname.lastname@example.org.